Understanding Prop 65

California's chemical disclosure law and what it means for your products.

California Proposition 65, formally the Safe Drinking Water and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986, requires a clear and reasonable warning before a business exposes people in California to a chemical on the state's list of chemicals known to cause cancer or reproductive toxicity. The state must revise and republish that list at least once a year (Health and Safety Code 25249.8(a)). The law's duties fall on a "person in the course of doing business", a term that leaves out small businesses (HSC 25249.11(b)). The regulations set the count: every full-time and part-time employee on the date of the exposure, and the law applies to a business with ten or more (27 CCR 25102(h)). A small importer's products can still need a warning: when no business up the chain is covered and has an agent for service of process or a place of business in California, a retailer that knows of the exposure must give the warning itself (27 CCR 25600.2(e)(5)).

Two exposure levels:

  • NSRL (No Significant Risk Level) — for chemicals listed as causing cancer. It is the level calculated to result in one excess case of cancer in an exposed population of 100,000, assuming lifetime exposure at that level (27 CCR 25703(b)).
  • MADL (Maximum Allowable Dose Level) — for chemicals listed as causing reproductive toxicity. It is the no-observable-effect level divided by 1,000 (27 CCR 25801(b)).

A business that shows an exposure falls below these levels does not need to warn, and the burden of showing it is on the business (HSC 25249.10(c)).

Safe-harbor warning formats (27 CCR 25603, as amended effective January 1, 2025):

  • Both formats start with the yellow warning triangle (not on food; see below) and the word WARNING: (or CA WARNING: or CALIFORNIA WARNING:) and point to www.P65Warnings.ca.gov.
  • Full-length warning — names at least one listed chemical, for example: "This product can expose you to chemicals including [chemical], which is known to the State of California to cause cancer. For more information go to www.P65Warnings.ca.gov."
  • Short-form warning — also names at least one chemical, for example: "Can expose you to [chemical], a carcinogen. See www.P65Warnings.ca.gov."
  • The older short form that names no chemical ("Cancer - www.P65Warnings.ca.gov.") may still be used on a product manufactured and labeled before January 1, 2028 (27 CCR 25603(c)).

Food and cosmetics are covered too. The regulations define a consumer product as "any article, or component part thereof, including food" (27 CCR 25600.1(d)), and food includes dietary supplements (27 CCR 25600.1(g)). The importer is one of the businesses that can give the warning, on the label or by written notice to the retailer (27 CCR 25600.2(b)).

Four rules importers often miss:

  • A contract can move the duty. A written agreement between you and the retailer that allocates who gives the warning decides it (27 CCR 25600.2(i)).
  • Retailers name the importer. A retailer served with a notice must name the businesses upstream of it, such as its supplier or importer (27 CCR 25600.2(g)).
  • Other languages. If the label has consumer information in another language, the warning must be in that language too (27 CCR 25602(d)).
  • Online sales. A product sold online needs the warning on the product page, through a "WARNING" link, or before the purchase (27 CCR 25602(b)). Until January 1, 2028, when you send a retailer an updated warning that replaces the old short form (25603(c)) with the new one (25603(b)), the retailer has 60 calendar days to show the new wording online (27 CCR 25602(b)(2)).

Food warnings are worded differently (27 CCR 25607.2):

  • They start "Consuming this product can expose you to…" and point to www.P65Warnings.ca.gov/food, for example: "Consuming this product can expose you to chemicals including [chemical], which is known to the State of California to cause cancer. For more information go to www.P65Warnings.ca.gov/food."
  • The short form also points to /food, for example: "Cancer risk from exposure to [chemical]. See www.P65Warnings.ca.gov/food."
  • The food rule has no warning triangle.
  • On a food label, the warning must be set off from the surrounding information and "enclosed in a box" (27 CCR 25607.1(b)).

Naturally occurring chemicals in food. Eating a food is not an exposure to a listed chemical to the extent the business can show the chemical is naturally occurring in the food, and only the part that did not come from human activity counts (27 CCR 25501). Two conditions apply (27 CCR 25501(a)(4)): the chemical counts as naturally occurring only to the extent "it was not avoidable by good agricultural or good manufacturing practices", and whoever produces, makes, distributes or holds the food must use quality control that reduces natural contaminants to the "lowest level currently feasible". The business has to show it.

Cosmetics have no warning rule of their own, so they use the general consumer-product warning above, with the triangle. Federal law does not displace Prop 65 warnings on cosmetics. A state may not set cosmetic labeling or packaging requirements that differ from federal ones (21 U.S.C. 379s(a)), but that rule "shall not apply to a State requirement adopted by a State public initiative or referendum enacted prior to September 1, 1997" (21 U.S.C. 379s(e)) — Prop 65 was adopted by initiative in 1986. MoCRA's own preemption covers only registration and product listing, good manufacturing practice, records, recalls, adverse event reporting and safety substantiation (21 U.S.C. 364j(a)), and leaves 379s as it was (364j(d)).

WARNING: A violation can bring a lawsuit for civil penalties (HSC 25249.7(b)). If you receive a notice, see Responding to a Prop 65 60-day notice.