Choosing FSVP supplier verification activities

Onsite audit, sampling and testing, records review, or another appropriate activity — how to pick the right verification activity per hazard.

Once your hazard analysis identifies hazards that require control at the foreign supplier, FSVP requires you to perform supplier verification activities to confirm those controls are working. The rule lists four kinds of activity, and before you import you must decide — and write down — which of them you will use for each supplier and how often (21 CFR 1.506(d)(1)(i)).

Four verification activities (21 CFR 1.506(d)(1)(ii)):

  • Onsite audit — physical inspection at the supplier's facility, performed by a qualified auditor. Highest evidentiary weight.
  • Sampling and testing — laboratory testing of incoming product or raw materials against the controlled hazard.
  • Review of the foreign supplier's relevant food safety records — documented evidence of the supplier's preventive controls (HACCP plans, monitoring records, corrective actions, training logs).
  • Other appropriate supplier verification activities — any other check that is appropriate given the supplier's performance and the risk of the food (21 CFR 1.506(e)(1)(iv)(A)). Because it has no fixed form, your record of it must include a description of the activity, the date it was done, its findings or results, any corrective actions, and documentation that a qualified individual did it (21 CFR 1.506(e)(1)(iv)(B)).

Picking the right activity (severity-driven):

  1. Hazard requiring a preventive control AND severe outcome (e.g., Salmonella in ready-to-eat foods) — if the hazard could cause serious illness or death and your supplier is the one controlling it, the default is an onsite audit before your first import and at least once a year after. You can rely on sampling and testing, a records review, or less frequent audits instead, but only if you make a written determination that they give adequate assurance, and keep it in your FSVP records (21 CFR 1.506(d)(2)).
  2. Hazard requiring a preventive control AND moderate outcome — any of the four activities can be the right one, including sampling and testing or a records review. You choose which, and how often, based on your evaluation of the food and the supplier, and you write that choice down before you import (21 CFR 1.506(d)(1)(i)).
  3. Hazard that will be controlled after import, by your customer or by someone later in the chain — this is not a supplier-verification case at all. For that hazard you are not required to evaluate the supplier or do verification activities under 21 CFR 1.505 and 1.506 (21 CFR 1.507(a)). Instead, the documents that travel with the food must say it is "not processed to control [the hazard]", and you must get a written assurance from your customer every year (21 CFR 1.507(a)(2)–(4)). What the assurance promises depends on who controls the hazard: that your customer follows procedures that will significantly minimize or prevent it ((a)(2)); that your customer makes the food in line with the food safety requirements that apply to it ((a)(3)); or, when a company after your customer controls it, that your customer will pass the same disclosure on and sell only to a company that agrees in writing to control the hazard or to get the same assurance from its own customer ((a)(4)). Each assurance must carry an effective date and the printed names and signatures of authorized officials (21 CFR 1.507(b)). The rule lists two other cases like this: a food that cannot be eaten without a control being applied, such as coffee beans or cocoa beans ((a)(1)), and a documented system of your own that ensures the hazard is controlled at a later step ((a)(5)).

Produce has its own hazard-analysis rule, not a separate path around FSVP. For a raw fruit or vegetable that is "covered produce" under the Produce Safety Rule (21 CFR 112.3), you don't have to decide whether its biological hazards require a control: the rule treats them as requiring one, addressed by compliance with part 112. You must still decide whether any other hazards require a control (21 CFR 1.504(e)), and the "no hazards requiring a control" shortcut does not apply to covered produce (21 CFR 1.504(f)), so supplier evaluation and verification still apply. Produce from a farm that is not covered by part 112 may qualify for the modified requirements in 21 CFR 1.512.

TIP: Records review is the lowest-cost option but the lowest evidentiary weight. Use it for low-severity hazards or as a supplement to sampling — rarely as the only verification for a high-risk hazard.

Frequency rules:

  • Onsite audits for hazards that could cause serious illness or death: before first import and at least annually, unless you have made a written determination that other activities or less frequent audits are adequate (21 CFR 1.506(d)(2))
  • Sampling and testing, a records review, or another appropriate activity: the rule sets no fixed interval. You decide how often, and document that decision before you import (21 CFR 1.506(d)(1)(i)). You then do the activity before importing and periodically after that (21 CFR 1.506(e)(1)), and promptly review and document the results (21 CFR 1.506(e)(3)).

Base the frequency on your evaluation of the food and the supplier: the rule requires your choice of activities, and how often you do them, to rest on that evaluation (21 CFR 1.506(d)(1)(i)). A frequency written down with no basis behind it does not meet that requirement.

Doing it in Aleph — schedule first, record when done

On a food product's Compliance tab, each supplier's FSVP rows offer these:

  • Schedule a verification — choose the activity (an onsite audit, sampling and testing, a records review, or another appropriate check) and how often, based on your evaluation of the supplier (21 CFR 1.506(d)(1)(i)). Saving it records your decision; it does not record that the activity was done.
  • Record a completed verification — once an audit, test, records review or other check is done, record what it found and your review of the results. If nothing is scheduled for that supplier yet, the form says so and its Schedule a verification button opens the scheduling form for that product and supplier. Aleph files a signed PDF in the product's documents and marks the scheduled activity completed. Record the next verification does the same for the next one.
  • A Last completed date typed into the scheduling form is kept and sets the next due date, but it does not complete a checklist row: it files no record of what was found or of your review. The supplier verification row, the onsite audit a serious hazard calls for and Onsite audit documentation each need the signed record from Record a completed verification. Until you file it, the supplier verification row shows the typed date and says to record it.
  • Schedule an onsite audit — the same scheduling form, for the onsite audit a serious hazard calls for unless you have made a written determination that other activities give adequate assurance (21 CFR 1.506(d)(2)). Once it is done, record it with the completed-verification form; it counts for 12 months from the date it was conducted.
  • Fill in evaluation & approval — answer the 21 CFR 1.505(a) questions and record your decision. Aleph files a signed evaluation PDF and, if you approve the supplier, a separate approval record. On a row that is already met the button reads Record a reevaluation.
  • Record a corrective action — only when you have found a problem with the supplier or the food. Aleph files a signed corrective-action PDF.
  • Sign written procedures — Aleph assembles the document from the decisions you recorded; review it and sign. It counts for every FSVP product, not just the one you signed it from. See "FSVP written procedures and signing them in Aleph".

WARNING: An onsite audit must be performed by a qualified auditor (21 CFR 1.506(e)(1)(i)(A)) — a qualified individual with the technical expertise to audit. The rule's own examples are a government employee and an audit agent of a certification body accredited under 21 CFR part 1, subpart M (21 CFR 1.500); a qualified individual may also be your own employee. The supplier's own internal auditor doesn't count: you may not rely on the foreign supplier or its employees to perform verification activities, except for sampling and testing (21 CFR 1.506(e)(2)(ii)).

Samples of what the forms above file, for a fictional company and marked FOR REFERENCE ONLY (each opens in a new tab):